The Steel of American Resolve: 9/11/01 at Chaminade
Updated: Nov 9

The October 2001 issue of Tarmac honored George Howard '75, who lost his life helping others.
by Blake Lou Weaver ’27
Tarmac had an exciting interview that was just getting lined up.
Bro. Stephen Balletta, S.M. ’74, the faculty moderator of the school’s student newspaper back in 2001, was busy arranging for the Bishop of the Solomon Islands, Christopher M. Cardone ’76, to speak with some of the writers on the Tarmac staff. Bishop Cardone was planning to come to town for a few days to visit his family and celebrate Chaminade’s opening school Mass, and Bro. Steve was making the final arrangements for some of his young reporters to snag a high-profile interview for the fall edition of the newspaper.
Thus, on the morning of September 11, 2001, Bro. Steve walked into the school receptionist’s office, located in Chaminade’s main lobby, with the intention of faxing details to Bishop Cardone to help him prepare for the interview.
Bro. Steve greeted Mrs. Jan O’Sullivan, the school’s longtime gatekeeper, as he passed her on his way to the fax machine. Just as he was finishing, he heard Mrs. O’Sullivan gasp.
“Oh my God!” she exclaimed. “A plane just hit the World Trade Center!”
Bro. Steve was shocked, but he assumed the aircraft to be a small propeller plane, one likely controlled by an inexperienced pilot who had made a terrible mistake. “Perhaps the pilot had a heart attack and lost control,” he thought. “This must be a tragic accident.”
Bro. Steve gathered his papers and walked across the hall into the office of Bro. Joseph Bellizzi, S.M. ’78, Chaminade’s principal at the time. He had been meaning to talk to Bro. Joe about the upcoming Mass and was excited to tell him about the interview he had arranged with the bishop. As the two men conversed, the news played on a tiny television in the corner of the room.
At 9:03 a.m., they looked up in unison as a commercial jet liner crashed into the side of the south tower, erupting into a massive fireball. “My gosh,” Bro. Steve said, “that is going to affect our kids.”
Parents and relatives of Chaminade students who worked in and around the World Trade Center flashed through Bro. Steve’s mind. Though shaken, he still did not realize the extent of what he and Bro. Joe had just watched.
The school’s administration quickly made the decision not to tell students anything until more details were known. In the meantime, Bro. Steve made his way to room 2, carrying on with his teaching responsibilities while holding on to a secret his students would soon learn.
Moments before Bro. Steve began teaching his second-period class, Bro. Thomas Cleary, S.M. ’81, walked past Bro. Steve’s office. Peeking inside, Bro. Tom did not find his fellow Marianist, but rather two of the school’s print shop workers sitting in an adjacent office, glued to a television screen.
“What is going on here?” he thought to himself. “Why are there two guys just sitting around watching television?”
Suddenly realizing Bro. Tom’s presence, the two men looked at him.
“Bro. Tom, you’ll never believe what just happened!” said one, as video of the plane hitting the tower was replayed.
Smoke was now visible from the top of the Brothers’ residence, but the students below were still unaware that the world they knew had been forever changed.
Just one week into his senior year of studies, Steve Penaro ’02 walked into his second-period English 12 class, looked around for an open seat, and took one beside his friends. Just before the bell rang, the class was abuzz with chatter, with some students discussing the previous night's Giants game and others whispering about something that Steve couldn’t quite make out.
After the bell rang and the teacher began talking about classical literature, Steve continued to hear whispers. He turned around and was told by one of his friends that a plane had hit one of the twin towers.
“An accident,” he thought, shocked. “It must be.”
As Steve sat in class wondering what could have gone wrong for the pilot of that plane, Fr. Garrett Long, S.M. ’62, was compiling a list of every student with a parent or relative who might have been in or near the World Trade Center. He began walking from classroom to classroom, quietly approaching students who may have been affected and telling them what had happened.
The word soon began to spread that this was something much worse than an accident. Eventually, it became clear that Fr. Garrett could no longer continue going door-to-door, and an announcement was made over the school’s loudspeaker system:
Any student who believed he may have a loved one working near the World Trade Center was to immediately report to Darby Auditorium.
Within minutes, hundreds of desperate students were scattered among the venue’s rows of mint-green chairs. Seniors sat beside freshmen, as students who had never met quizzed each other for details about what was occurring.
It was rare for a student to have a cell phone in 2001, and those who did enjoy the luxury normally borrowed a parent’s device when out at night or on the weekend. Therefore, there were no sources for up-to-the-minute information. Instead, students from different towns, classes, and grades gathered together as a cloud of doubt and despair formed inside Darby.
Marc Munfa ’02 didn’t understand the full scale and devastation of what was going on. He assumed that the only people who would be hurt or killed were those who had been on the planes. He still recalls the moment he realized the gravity of the situation - speaking with a faculty member, Marc lamented the hundreds of lives that certainly had been lost among passengers on the aircrafts. In response, his teacher just shook his head before nearly whispering the day’s harsh reality:
“Marc, many people in those buildings are going to die. It’s going to be in the thousands.”
For Marc, Steve, and many other Chaminade students, September 11, 2001 marked the end of an era of innocence. For them, it was the day they realized that the world could be a dangerous place. People could enact harm in unimaginable ways. People could be hurt. People could die.
Suffering was real.
Penaro still remembers lying in his bed on the night of September 11, struggling to meet with sleep as he listened to the sound of fighter jets flying over his house, heading towards Manhattan. When he awoke the next morning, he knew his world was never going to be the same.
Four of his classmates had dads who went to work on Tuesday morning and never came home.
Fifteen Chaminade alumni were killed in the attacks.
When President Bush addressed Congress the week after 9/11, he held up the shield of Port Authority Police Officer George Howard, a graduate of Chaminade’s class of 1975.
When the dust finally settled, over 75 Chaminade families had lost a loved one in the attacks.

Photos from the October 2001 issue of Tarmac
Twenty-five years later, memories of that day are still vivid enough to move the strongest to tears.
Lives were lost. Society was changed. The world has never been the same.
In the face of such profound and personal loss, Chaminade remained strong. Built on a foundation rooted in unity, the school community demonstrated the strength to rebuild, honor, and remember. The embodiment of the school’s motto - Strength in Unity - coupled with deep faith saw the Chaminade family through such tragedy.
Today, a quarter-century after that dark day, the early premonitions of so many staff and students have proven correct - the world changed forever on that September 11. Chaminade did not, however, as its strength proved to be something somehow stronger than steel - a fortes forged by the unbreakable bonds of brotherhood.
.png)